Ethics of Vaccine Refusal

Michael Kowalik

Proponents of vaccine mandates typically claim that everyone who can be vaccinated has a moral or ethical obligation to do so for the sake of those who cannot be vaccinated, or in the interest of public health. I evaluate several previously under-theorised premises implicit to the ‘obligation to vaccinate’ type of arguments and show that the general conclusion is false: there is neither a moral obligation to vaccinate nor a sound ethical basis to mandate vaccination under any circumstances, even for hypothetical vaccines that are medically risk-free. Agent-autonomy with respect to self-constitution has absolute normative priority over reduction or elimination of the associated risks to life. In practical terms, mandatory vaccination amounts to discrimination against healthy, innate biological characteristics, which goes against the established ethical norms and is also defeasible a priori.

Latest articles

Madhava Setty Primum non nocere, “first and foremost, I will do no...
Emily Kopp and Karolina Corin A team of Western virologists could face...
privacyisyourright.ca Using the declaration of a pandemic as an excuse, the CPSO...
Aric Cox Many of you have been on protocol, after protocol, after...
Jeffrey Jaxen Talking to the news host, German Health Minister Karl Lauterbach...
Merinda Teller Over the past six decades, solid organ transplantation has gone...

Thank you!

Thank you for your membership application. As soon as your payment has been received your membership will be activated and you will be informed via email.

Thank you.

Thank you!

The form has been submitted successfully!