How the CDC Abandoned Science

Vinay Prasad

The main federal agency guiding America’s pandemic policy is the U.S. Centers for Disease Control, which sets widely adopted policies on masking, vaccination, distancing, and other mitigation efforts to slow the spread of COVID and ensure the virus is less morbid when it leads to infection. The CDC is, in part, a scientific agency—they use facts and principles of science to guide policy—but they are also fundamentally a political agency: The director is appointed by the president of the United States, and the CDC’s guidance often balances public health and welfare with other priorities of the executive branch.

Throughout this pandemic, the CDC has been a poor steward of that balance, pushing a series of scientific results that are severely deficient. This research is plagued with classic errors and biases, and does not support the press-released conclusions that often follow. In all cases, the papers are uniquely timed to further political goals and objectives; as such, these papers appear more as propaganda than as science. The CDC’s use of this technique has severely damaged their reputation and helped lead to a growing divide in trust in science by political party. Science now risks entering a death spiral in which it will increasingly fragment into subsidiary verticals of political parties. As a society, we cannot afford to allow this to occur. Impartial, honest appraisal is needed now more than ever, but it is unclear how we can achieve it.

Latest articles

Swiss Policy Research … data from both Germany and Switzerland does show...
Kenji Yamamoto Recently, The Lancet published a study on the effectiveness of...
Kit Knightly Polio is on the front pages of British newspapers again...
Carey Gillam Glyphosate, a synthetic herbicide patented in 1974 by the Monsanto...
Suzanne Burdick A study published last week in Environment International showed 29...

Your donation helps us
stand up for health freedom!

Canada Health Alliance is volunteer run and 100% supported by the generous donations of those who share our concerns and value our work.

Stay up to date

Sign up to our newsletter to get the latest health-related news and events delivered straight to your inbox.

Become a CHA member

Become an active value-added member and trusted provider of medical and healthcare information and education by joining the CHA Membership Program.

Your donation helps us stand up for health freedom!

Canada Health Alliance is volunteer run and 100% supported by the generous donations of those who share our concerns and value our work.